When a cast member is murdered, the game's other players take a stab at finding the killer.
| Name | Type | Role | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sam Reich | Host | ||
| Grant O'Brien | Guest Star | ||
| Christine Medrano | Guest Star | ||
| Rekha Shankar | Guest Star | ||
| Avery Monsen | Guest Star | ||
| Josh Ruben | Guest Star | ||
| Evan Watkins | Guest Star | ||
| Ashley Kron | Guest Star | ||
| Andy Bustillos | Guest Star |