It's like deja vu all over again for Trapp, Ify, and Siobhan. Content Warning: Coulrophobia (Clown): [5:44-6:54, 15:42-16:38, 24:52-25:51, 32:12-32:47, 39:30-40:34]
| Name | Type | Role | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sam Reich | Host | ||
| Ify Nwadiwe | Guest Star | Contestant | |
| Josh Ruben | Guest Star | ||
| Siobhan Thompson | Guest Star | Contestant | |
| Mike Trapp | Guest Star | Contestant | |
| Brian David Gilbert | Guest Star | ||
| ProZD / SungWon Cho | Guest Star | ||
| Zac Oyama | Guest Star |