White OTH certainly had its episodes where multiple girls were in love with the same guy, we don't think there's ever been a case where three girls have fallen in love with one episode. That is...until now. Hilarie, Joy, and Sophia go head over heels for this rewatch. Find out what part of the episode they wish had happened IRL, why they want to bring it to Broadway, and what incident Hilarie and Sophia couldn't help but tease Joy about.