Donnie and Jenny both have kids from their previous marriages, but being newlyweds opens up a question--should they have a baby together? Or should they enjoy this third chapter of their lives as parents of fast growing kids? As they weigh the pros and cons, Donnie's friends and Jenny's sister, JoJo, aren't convinced that the couple can still handle a newborn with their busy schedules. So, to test their theory, the gang forces Donnie and Jenny to put up or shut up.