In this episode of Claire Recreates, Claire takes on the challenge of making homemade Nutter Butters completely from scratch. She bakes crunchy peanut shaped cookies and fills them with creamy peanut butter frosting. From mixing the dough to shaping the classic peanut design and testing the filling, Claire shows every step of the process as she compares homemade vs store bought Nutter Butters. Does the DIY version hold up against the nostalgic packaged cookie? Watch to find out. If you have ever wondered how to make Nutter Butter cookies at home or wanted to see how they compare to the original, this video has the recipes, techniques, and taste test you are looking for.