Maura Tierney wins.
| Name | Type | Role | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Rosario Dawson | Guest Star | ||
| Michael Ian Black | Guest Star | ||
| Lauren Graham | Guest Star | ||
| Dulé Hill | Guest Star | ||
| Jon Favreau | Guest Star | ||
| James Blake | Guest Star | ||
| Andy Richter | Guest Star | ||
| Tom Everett Scott | Guest Star | ||
| Maura Tierney | Guest Star |