Andy Richter is throwing a dinner party for musician Coolio and Chef Damaris Phillips, who will compete against Chef Richard Blais and Emmy-winning actress Kristen Johnston. Andy's guests must talk with a mouth full of crackers, try and spell the name of various foods and complete common kitchen tasks while tied to their teammate with an apron. At the end of the night, the winning team gets the golden dinner plate and the losing team is stuck with dish duty in Andy's kitchen.