Nick Gorman, who tries in vain to meet Johnny Arthur, is killed in a hit-and-run accident. Barnaby poses as a man on a fishing trip to investigate. The townspeople Flory, Johnson, Spake and Rile draw lots on who should kill Barnaby. They all acquired sudden wealth.
| Name | Type | Role | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Steve Fisher | Writer | ||
| Jay W. MacIntosh | Guest Star | ||
| Dabbs Greer | Guest Star | ||
| Florida Friebus | Guest Star | ||
| James Luisi | Guest Star | ||
| Claude Akins | Guest Star | ||
| Richard Yniguez | Guest Star | ||
| Neva Patterson | Guest Star | ||
| Geoffrey Lewis | Guest Star | ||
| Lou Frizzell | Guest Star | ||
| Marc Daniels | Director |