Cases Profiled: Anibal Mustelier, Edwin Rodriguez, William Bishop, Janette Piro killer, O. C. Smith attacker, Elizabeth Smart abductor, Bert Mercer, Elizabeth Smart, Christopher Benedetto
| Name | Type | Role | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Lucy Brightman | Guest Star | ||
| Michael Staulbaum | Guest Star | ||
| Ryan Pangretic | Guest Star | ||
| Randy Perillo | Guest Star | ||
| Richard Foster | Guest Star | ||
| Kay DeGiorgi | Guest Star |