Seven divorced singles move into a mansion with their exes and will depend on them to find new love. While some exes miss the mark with their matchmaking, feelings resurface for others watching their former partners fall in love with someone new.
Tara challenges Peter to step up and find her a good match, Nicole's Sweet Suite experiences leave something to be desired, and one single moves too fast during a date at Churchill Downs.
Amina tries to fulfill Peter's vague match request, Jeremy has a heated exchange with a single, Troy shocks with his pick for Pam and Justin's date reveals her connection to Britney Spears.
Mike Mike feels pressured to find a match for Nicole, Ugo resents Gary's advances toward Amarachi, Jeremy and Tina's romance heats up, and Bow Wow introduces a special guest to the house.
A dater explodes when she finds out her ex is attempting to sabotage her new relationship. Meanwhile, an ex rolls the dice on a second chance with his former spouse, and another ex begs his former wife to reconcile their marriage.
The men of the house confront their jealous feelings toward their exes; Bow surprises everyone by allowing the daters to attend the next singles party, solo.
Bow throws one last party with every single who dated during the experience; at the final Love 'Em or Leave 'Em, the daters must decide who to pursue their After Happily Ever After with, prompting a single to get on one knee to propose.