The contestants must decipher their first task from a series of clues and stack the lowest unique number of doughnuts on a stick.
| Name | Type | Role | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Kate Berlant | Guest Star | ||
| Dillon Francis | Guest Star | ||
| Lisa Lampanelli | Guest Star | ||
| Ron Funches | Guest Star | ||
| Freddie Highmore | Guest Star |