Freshly engaged Nicole is having second thoughts as she wonders if the one she's really meant to be with is her mystery college pen pal whose letters she has kept all these years.
Sydney has transitioned from a track star to a successful food blogger. Moreover, her heart is still attached to her college boyfriend. However, they have not seen each other in a decade.
Lauren tries to achieve her dream of opening an art gallery while dealing with her mixed emotions about her husband. She recruits The Love Club to help her move on, but instead they come up with a plan to keep them together.
Tara, a free spirit with a beautiful singing voice, has always professed she doesn't need a partner or so-called commitment. When her friends see her connection with Noah, their job turns into matchmaking.